Conformity gate
Apothem conformity gate — the mechanical fraction of the fifteen-bar pre-emission gate (M1-M15) every emitted artifact must pass.
The fifteen bars
| Bar | ID | Mandate | Check class | Failure → action |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | M1 | Host-Project Agnosticism | Reasoned | Revise to match host conventions |
| 2 | M2 | Editorial Discipline (disclosure ledger) | Reasoned | Add disclosure markers |
| 3 | M3 | Ten Quality Dimensions | Mechanical + reasoned | Revise on failing dimensions |
| 4 | M4 | Self-application (verification block present) | Reasoned | Record the verification block |
| 5 | M5 | Authority Principle (no fabricated identity / endpoint / secret) | Mechanical | Route to inquiry |
| 6 | M6 | Expertise Incorporation (surfaced gaps) | Reasoned | Surface gaps; cite refinements |
| 7 | M7 | Option Annotation (Recommended marker + driver rationale) | Mechanical | Annotate option sets |
| 8 | M8 | Definitiveness (no hedging in prescriptive prose) | Mechanical | Promote hedges to conditionals |
| 9 | M9 | Visual Leverage (structural subjects carry diagrams) | Mechanical + reasoned | Author / refresh diagram |
| 10 | M10 | Bidirectional Binding (reciprocal back-pointers closed) | Mechanical | Close half-edges |
| 11 | M11 | Agile Sprints (Goal / Backlog / DoR / DoD / Review / Retrospective) | Reasoned | Restructure as sprints |
| 12 | M12 | Phase Reporting & Canonical Layout | Mechanical + reasoned | Author rollup; relocate to canonical layout |
| 13 | M13 | Code Craft (lint / format / type-check; magic-number; bare-except) | Mechanical | Apply per-language code-craft rules |
| 14 | M14 | Systemicity (declares upstream / downstream / peers / enforcers) | Mechanical + reasoned | Declare; index in registries |
| 15 | M15 | Production-Ready (tests + docs + CHANGELOG + conformant commit + CI green + semver-stability) | Mechanical + reasoned | Add missing surfaces |
The gate runs only machine-checkable validators. The reasoned judgment that the Reasoned bars call for, and the reasoned half of each Mechanical + reasoned bar, is evaluated in review.
Severity ladder
The gate has no Critical, Important or Advisory ladder and no two-finding threshold. Without --strict (or APOTHEM_CONFORMITY_STRICT=1), the gate reports findings and exits 0. With --strict, a single-file or hook check exits 2 when any matcher fails, and a corpus run (--all or --all-perwrite) exits 2 when a blocking validator or matcher fails; advisory findings are reported only. The installed Write/Edit hook does not pass --strict, so it reports findings and the write proceeds unless APOTHEM_CONFORMITY_STRICT=1 is set in its environment.
Validators
The mechanical fraction lives at src/apothem/conformity/, orchestrated by src/apothem/conformity/gate.py.
Each validator runs in one of three ways:
- per-write: on every pending write (
--hook), or on every tracked file with--all-perwrite. - standalone: across the whole repository with
--all, or one at a time with--check <name>. - change-set: against a staged diff, run directly as
python -m apothem.conformity.semver_stability_grep --staged, not through the gate.
The table below is generated from the validator modules.
The conformity package ships 54 validators: 22 per-write, 31 standalone and 1 change-set. The gate registers the per-write and standalone ones.
| Validator | Runs | Rule anchor | What it checks |
|---|---|---|---|
agent-capability-grep | standalone | agent-capability-discipline (per-harness capability matrix) | Verify every harness declares its agentic-capability matrix. |
agents-md-coverage-grep | standalone | rules/agents-md-convention.md | Flag stale agent-companion files under the root-only AGENTS.md convention. |
agnosticism-grep | standalone | rules/agnostic-posture.md §3 (harness neutrality) + §1 (default-off) | Flag harness bias and re-introduced enforcement presets in shipped surfaces. |
always-on-budget-grep | per-write | D1 token-budget-discipline §Always-on body budget | Body-budget conformity matcher for always-on rules. Pointed at a rules directory it also holds the loaded always-on set and the rule index to byte ceilings. |
bare-except-grep | per-write | M13.3 error handling | Flag bare except clauses without typed exceptions or re-raise. |
binding-five-direction-grep | standalone | M10 bidirectional-binding §1 (five-direction Bindings section) | Require the five-direction Bindings section on every rule, command, agent, and skill. |
binding-reciprocity-corpus-grep | standalone | M10 bidirectional-binding §2 (↔ self-reciprocal) | Cross-file binding-reciprocity corpus walk — the ↔-symmetric half-edge check. |
binding-reciprocity-grep | per-write | M10 bidirectional-binding §Notation | Flag binding declarations using non-canonical arrow notation. |
brand-mark-grep | per-write | rules/plain-language.md (brand-mark display/identifier casing) | Flag brand-mark display/identifier form drift on brand-touched surfaces. |
commented-out-code-grep | per-write | M13.1 why-not-what comments | Flag substantial commented-out code blocks left in source. |
completion-claim-grep | per-write | rules/session-closure.md (verifiable-close output honesty) | Flag unsupported completion / guarantee claims in cohort prose. |
conventional-commit-grep | standalone | CLAUDE.md Coding Conventions — Conventional Commits | Flag HEAD commit messages that drift from the Conventional-Commits grammar. |
copilot-instructions-presence-grep | per-write | — | GitHub Copilot surface presence check. |
cross-platform-matrix-grep | standalone | cross-platform OS x Python CI matrix | Verify CI declares a cross-platform OS x Python matrix. |
determinism-grep | standalone | rules/determinism.md | Prove every command and skill surface has a deterministic output shape. |
diagram-staleness-grep | per-write | M9 visual-leverage §Fidelity | Flag diagrams whose verification date is missing or stale. |
dynamism-grep | standalone | rules/dynamism.md (static-version embeds) | Flag static-string version embeds in dynamism-required surfaces. |
editorconfig-presence-grep | standalone | supply-chain SOTA-rigor §editorconfig | Verify a canonical .editorconfig is present at the project root. |
file-header-grep | per-write | — | Authorship-header presence and canonical-form check. |
freshness-token-grep | standalone | rules/freshness-facade.md | Flag freshness-narrative phrases on shipped public surfaces. |
frontmatter-grep | per-write | the per-class frontmatter JSON Schemas (src/apothem/schemas/) | Validate per-artifact-class YAML frontmatter against required-key sets. |
frontmatter-value-grep | standalone | per-class JSON Schema enum/pattern value constraints | Validate frontmatter VALUES against the per-class JSON Schema enum/pattern constraints. |
gate-evidence-grep | standalone | commands/plan-execute.md Gate evidence; rules/pre-emission-gate-bars.md section 2 (attestation schema) | Advisory: flag plan-suite gate claims that lack a command, an exit status or output, and a HEAD SHA beside them, and fifteen-bar attestations that omit a field of the rule's schema. |
gitattributes-presence-grep | standalone | supply-chain .gitattributes contract | Verify the repo-root .gitattributes carries the canonical contract. |
harden-runner-grep | standalone | harden-runner egress baseline | Verify every workflow job opens with a conformant harden-runner step. |
hedging-grep | per-write | M8 definitiveness §Hedging | Flag hedging vocabulary in prescriptive contexts. |
license-author-consistency-grep | per-write | — | LICENSE author-identity presence check. |
link-check | per-write | rules/code-craft-markdown.md §6 Link Discipline | Validate Markdown internal links against the on-disk reference graph. |
magic-number-grep | per-write | M13.10 magic numbers | Flag magic numbers in source code. |
multi-surface-coherence-grep | per-write | — | Shared-claim coherence across AI-conventions surfaces. |
naming-grep | standalone | CLAUDE.md Coding Conventions (kebab-case naming) | Validate filesystem paths against the canonical naming convention. |
no-global-plans-grep | standalone | CLAUDE.md Plans Discipline (no global plans) | Walk the git index for tracked plans paths; fail when found. |
no-toplevel-docs-grep | standalone | single-source-of-truth (docs live in site/, not root docs/) | Fail when a top-level docs/ directory exists at the repository root. |
oidc-trusted-publishing-grep | standalone | OIDC trusted publishing | Verify release workflows use OIDC trusted publishing. |
option-annotation-grep | per-write | M7 option-annotation (H6 per-option bind) | Enforce the per-option Recommended label-to-body bind (H6). |
orphan-output-grep | per-write | M12 canonical-layout + M14 systemicity | Flag artifacts emitted to non-canonical locations or without provenance. |
permissions-minimum-scope-grep | standalone | minimum-scope workflow permissions | Verify every GitHub Actions workflow declares a minimum-scope permissions: block. |
plain-language-grep | standalone | rules/plain-language.md — user-facing prose | Flag mechanistic / harness-internal vocabulary in user-facing prose. |
plan-next-step-consistency-grep | standalone | rules/recommend-next-step.md | Advisory: flag plan-suite infra files whose Recommended-Next-Step footer drifts from the suite's recorded next pipeline stage. |
plan-suite-structure-grep | standalone | context-management-scratch 2 (suite-locality + closed vocab) + canonical-layout-reporting-tiers 2.1 (numeric-prefix discipline) | Validate plan-suite structure: suite-locality, closed vocab, numeric prefix. |
plans-discipline-language-grep | standalone | CLAUDE.md Plans Discipline (multi-surface language) | Verify the canonical Plans Discipline language reaches every required surface. |
production-ready-pr-grep | per-write | M15 production-ready §Same-change-set | Flag commits whose change-set lacks the production-ready four-class shape. |
recommend-next-step-grep | standalone | rules/recommend-next-step.md | Verify every command file carries a ## Recommended Next Step block. |
redundancy-grep | standalone | rules/operational-mandates.md §CM-7 coherent-product non-redundancy | Flag substantively-duplicated paragraphs across the governed corpus. |
reference-token-grep | standalone | rules/own-voice-reimplementation.md | Flag leaked reference-platform branding tokens on authored surfaces. |
registry-capability-consistency-grep | standalone | rules/agent-capability-discipline.md — registry capability cells backed by evidence | Flag registry capability cells not backed by install / materializer / projection evidence. |
secret-leak-grep | per-write | M13.8 security + M15 production-ready | Block emission of artifacts containing hardcoded credentials. |
semver-stability-grep | change-set | M15 semver-stability | Semver stability matcher (M15 mechanical fraction). |
smoke-install-grep | standalone | production-ready section 8.1 paired install scripts | Smoke-test the paired install scripts at the repository root. |
static-version-grep | standalone | rules/dynamism.md §static-version-resolution | Verify version-bearing sites resolve dynamically, not as static literals. |
token-efficiency-grep | per-write | clean-room-generation §5 + token-efficiency-rewrite | Flag filler phrases, throat-clearing openers, and content-free qualifiers. |
unpinned-action-grep | per-write | M15 production-ready §Supply-chain | Flag GitHub Actions workflows that pin actions to mutable refs. |
user-confirm-grep | per-write | M5 authority-inquiry §10 | Block emission of artifacts containing unresolved authority placeholders. |
workflow-concurrency-grep | standalone | workflow concurrency + per-job timeouts | Enforce concurrency + per-job timeout discipline on GitHub workflows. |
Running the gate
On an installed harness the gate runs automatically: Claude Code's
settings.json wires it as a PreToolUse hook that invokes the
materialized copy at ~/.claude/.apothem/support/conformity/gate.py before every
Write/Edit. The gate then checks only writes under its hook scope, and a write
outside the scope passes silently; Running the conformity gate
lists the scope. From a source checkout, the module form drives the same code;
prefix each python command below with PYTHONPATH=src. The
gate is advisory by default: it reports findings and exits 0. Add --strict
to exit 2 on a blocking finding. An unknown validator name exits 3.
# Every standalone validator across the repository:
python -m apothem.conformity.gate --all .
# The same sweep, failing on a blocking finding (the CI form):
python -m apothem.conformity.gate --all --strict .
# Every per-write validator against every tracked file:
python -m apothem.conformity.gate --all-perwrite .
# One validator by name (names come from --list):
python -m apothem.conformity.gate --check naming-grep .
# List every registered validator as JSON:
python -m apothem.conformity.gate --list
# Single-file dispatch (mimics the PreToolUse hook):
echo '{"tool_input": {"file_path": "path/to/file", "content": "..."}}' \
| python -m apothem.conformity.gate --hookpython -m apothem.conformity.gate --help prints the usage summary.
See Running the conformity gate for the full procedure.
Reference
- Pre-emission gate registry — canonical bar definitions
- Outward conformity registry — M1-M15 detailed semantics
- Cross-cutting mandates — mandate source of truth
- Performance discipline — per-class runtime budgets
Binary artifacts sweep
Apothem binary-artifacts sweep — zero compiled / packaged binaries tracked in source. OpenSSF Scorecard Binary-Artifacts check evidence.
Runbooks
Apothem runbooks — step-by-step operational procedures for releases, publisher setup, Pages enablement, recovery, and adapter authoring.